5 Perfect HelloFresh Tex Mex Paste Substitutes for All

Do you love spicy food? HelloFresh produces the best Tex-Mex paste having the most amazing flavor. The superb taste goes so well with burritos, tacos, nachos, and more!

HelloFresh Tex Mex paste’s popularity became a surprise even for the brand itself. It’s the delicious paste they include in many HelloFresh meal kit packs. 

But what would you do if you ran out of this paste? Let’s discover the 5 best Tex-Mex paste substitutes.

What is Tex-Mex Paste?

The Tex-Mex paste is a blend of tomato puree, spices, and sauces, giving the taste of Tex-Mex food. It is an adorable tasteful combination of Texan and Mexican food.

However, Tex-Mex paste does not follow the truly authentic Mexican tradition. But it sure adds a delightful taste to numerous dishes. 

Hats off to the one who came up with this wonderful creative idea by the way! 🙂

If you have been short of Tex-Mex paste to cook food, and can’t find any in your local stores either, have a look at these Tex-Mex sauce substitutes:

Can any Paste Substitute HelloFresh Tex Mex Paste?

Well, not, but we can find similar options as the Tex-Mex paste substitutes. 

This genius mix of tomato puree, spices, and sauces adds an explosion of taste to your dishes. 

Not only your Tex-Mex dishes, but this paste also can enhance the flavors of many other dishes on your dinner table. 

HelloFresh is a popular food delivery service that adds Tex Mex paste with other ingredients to the parcel. This is to make home cooking much easier and simpler for you. The matchless quality of the products made the brand’s food so amazingly popular among the masses!

We do not know the exact Tex Mex ingredients and ratios that HelloFresh has on its list, and they do not sell this paste individually at stores. But a few nice Tex-Mex paste substitutes will surely help the readers if they can only purchase part of the HelloFresh meal kit. 

Best HelloFresh Tex Mex Paste Substitutes

The closest Tex-Mex sauce replacement would be achiote paste. It is a commonly available Mexican ingredient with a nutty, earthy flavor. The best base for rubs for chicken, sauces, and many more dishes. 

Could not find achiote paste? No worries! You will surely find canned chipotle that’s a spicier version to level up the taste of your food. 

1. Achiote Paste

When we talk about the best Tex-Mex paste substitutes, achiote paste tops the list!

It is a very popular ingredient in Mexican food tradition and continues to give recipes a deliciously unique taste!

Another name for achiote paste is Recado Rojo. The ingredient has it’s signature dark orange or red color. It is made from dried herbs and a few spices. The spices include salt, black pepper, annatto, cumin, garlic, oregano, and more.  

You can prepare your own achiote paste if you have none. Here are the steps:

1. To make it, use white vinegar, oregano, paprika, garlic, and cumin. 
2. Place all these ingredients in a bowl and stir them all well. 
3. When combined, it makes the paste you can use in your dishes easy. 

Also, try our 5 Best Achiote Paste Substitutes for Your Recipes. 

2. Adobo Sauce

Adobo sauce is another fine Tex-Mex paste substitute for your dishes. It’s a sizzling sauce matching Tex-Mex and Mexican cuisine well.

Adobo sauce is made from vinegar, garlic, and dried herbs like achiote paste. 

Even so, the major difference is the addition of chili powder to adobo sauce. Moreover, adobo sauce has a dark orange, brownish color and a texture similar to barbecue sauce. 

It is easy to find adobo sauce in local stores and make your own at home. Follow the steps below:

1. You’ll need to get dried herbs, fresh tomatoes, salt, olive oil, chili powder, garlic cloves, vinegar, brown sugar, and oregano. 
2. Next, you’ll have to mix chili powder with hot water. 
3. Add tomatoes(fresh, paste, or canned) and vinegar. Stir this mixture well.
4. Then, add seasonings, including black pepper, cumin, cinnamon, and other ingredients you want. Blend them all again. 
5. Add a few cloves of garlic, salt, brown sugar, and oregano. Blend them again. 
6. The mix should acquire a rich, creamy consistency. Place this mixture in a pan, and add 1 to 2 tablespoons of olive oil. The heat should be set to medium or high. 
7. Bring this mixture to a boil, then let it simmer for 15 to 20 minutes. 
8. It is ready when the mix gets a dark orange color and creamy, smooth, barbecue sauce-like consistency. 

Learn more about the 10 best Substitutes for Adobo Sauce you can try in your recipes. 

3. Chipotle Sauce

Chipotle sauce is another perfect name on our Tex-Mex paste substitutes list. It has a mildly spicy flavor, which is similar to adobo sauce. However, it has slightly changed texture and flavor. 

It’s similar to adobo sauce with a tiny twist, particularly in terms of texture and flavor. Chipotle sauce is creamier than adobo sauce. It is made from adobo chipotles, plain yogurt, Mexican cream, lime, and garlic. The soft texture of the Mexican cream softens the sauce and makes it thinner than others. 

The adobo chipotles add smoky spiciness to the dishes. These specific chipotles lower chipotle peppers’ spice levels and make the sauce mild. It is perfect for those who have low heat tolerance being easy on our taste buds. 

It is easy to find chipotle sauce in stores all over the world. You can also create your own using this method:

1. Mix garlic, salt, honey, olive oil, and smoked jalapenos. 
2. Mix all these ingredients well to get a firm consistency.
3. Add a bit of Greek Yogurt.
4. Blend this mix well, and your homemade chipotle sauce is ready to serve!

Get some amazing ideas about the 5 Best Chipotle Sauce Substitutes!

4. Sriracha Sauce

Why not get your hands on a quicker replacement for Tex-Mex paste that is easily available in stores? It is sriracha sauce that can save your day!

You might already have this in your cutlery. Note that sriracha is much thicker than an ordinary hot sauce. Furthermore, it has a sweet, garlicky taste. It does not taste the same as Tex-Mex paste, but it gives your meals the spice kick you are craving. 

User Tip: Adding a bit of mayonnaise to the sriracha sauce will enhance its consistency and make the flavor more balanced. 

Learn more about 10 Spicy Substitutes for Sriracha Sauce.

5. Your Homemade HelloFresh Tex-Mex Paste Recipe

You can be as creative as you wish and try making a substitute for Tex-Mex in your kitchen. To do just that, follow the steps below:

1. Peel off garlic cloves. 
2. Place them on aluminum foil.
3. Sprinkle olive oil on them. 
4. Envelop the garlic in the foil. Let them sit in the oven until soft. You can keep them there for about 40 to 45 minutes. 
5. Meanwhile, place dried chilies in a pan and a little water. Bring that to a boil. 
6. Let it simmer for 20 minutes. 
7. As you wait for chili and garlic to prepare, combine ingredients for blending. Put a diced onion, roasted drained tomatoes, and softened chilies in the blender. 
8. Blend all these ingredients well until smooth and creamy. 
9. Place this mixture into the pan. Keep the heat at medium to low. 
10. Add other ingredients, including vinegar, tomato, chili paste, and roasted garlic. 
11. Also, don’t forget to add dry ingredients such as garlic powder, chili powder, cumin, oregano, coriander, paprika, salt, and some sugar. 
12. Allow this mix to simmer for about 15 to 20 minutes. 
13. Turn off the heat.
14. Allow it to cool. Your homemade Tex-Mex paste alternative is ready to serve. 

Best Way to Choose the Best Tex Mex Paste Substitutes?

You can get plenty of alternatives for substituting Tex Mex paste, keeping the following factors in mind will help you select the best one. 

1. Use adobo or chipotle sauce if you require a smoother, creamier consistency. 

2. When searching for a thicker consistency, go for achiote sauce. You can also choose sriracha for a thicker consistency again. Yet its additional benefit is it is easily available on the market. 

3. If you dare to invest your time wisely and collect the right ingredients, preparing your own sauce at home is always the best idea. Recreate this well-known HelloFresh Tex Mex paste in your own unique way and surprise the whole family. There is no need to add any preservatives to your recipe for good, either!

Bear in mind that there are no perfect HelloFresh Tex Mex paste substitutes. It depends on the above factors, your personal taste, and the availability of ingredients. 

Wrapping It Up

It is possible to find a reasonable Tex-Mex paste substitute. You might also get similar tasting substitutes to the HelloFresh Tex Mex paste or start making your own at home. However, knowing about some of the best replacement options for everything to be used in your kitchen is good. 

Having this post read, we hope you enjoy your most delicious and tempting Tex-Mex dinner after having this post read and if you are a Hellofresh lover then you most probably like HelloFresh Firecracker Meatballs 🙂